|
28 | 28 |
|
29 | 29 | ## Learnings |
30 | 30 |
|
| 31 | +### 2026-03-05T[NOW]: Read-Only PR Assessment — 4 Open PRs (#182, #185, #178, #131) |
| 32 | +- **Task:** Brady requested read-only assessment of 4 open PRs (all except #189 which Tamir is still working on). Scope: Summary, Quality, Compatibility with recent main, Recommended action. |
| 33 | +- **Context:** Recent main (HEAD: 1dc3bb6) shows major TS replatform: migration from `index.js` (deprecated) to `packages/squad-cli/dist/cli-entry.ts` (new architecture). doctor command already wired, nap command restored, migration docs clarified. This creates compatibility assessment challenge: PRs based on old JS architecture may conflict. |
| 34 | +- **Findings:** |
| 35 | + - **PR #182 (doctor command, Kaleb Cole, feat/doctor-command → main):** ✅ Code quality solid, but ⚠️ **REDUNDANT IMPLEMENTATION.** Modifies deprecated `index.js`. Recent main commit (15f4120, "fix: wire squad doctor command into CLI entry point") already implemented doctor in new TS architecture (`cli-entry.ts`). Both implementations would coexist, doubling maintenance burden. Recommendation: **MERGE WITH CAUTION** — Brady should verify if legacy `index.js` is still active or if this PR should be ported to TS codebase. |
| 36 | + - **PR #185 (template path fix, William Hallatt, squad/fix-template-install-path → dev):** ✅ **MERGE TO DEV.** Solid backport. Fixes 2-year-old path mismatch (templates installed to `.squad-templates/` but referenced as `.squad/templates/`). Targets dev branch (separate from main), doesn't conflict with TS replatform. All 95 tests pass. Low risk, high UX value. |
| 37 | + - **PR #178 (GitLab Issues docs, Carlos Sardo, dev → dev):** ✅ **MERGE TO DEV.** Well-written documentation. Mirrors GitHub Issues guide structure. Marks feature as experimental appropriately. No code impact. Commands verified against official glab docs. Only verification: confirm glab CLI docs haven't shifted since PR creation. |
| 38 | + - **PR #131 (remote squad mode, Shayne Boyer, feat/remote-squad-mode → main):** 🔴 **REQUEST CHANGES or CLOSE AS SUPERSEDED.** Mature architecture (9 days old, last updated 2026-02-22 before TS replatform). Proposes elegant dual-root resolver (`resolveSquadPaths()`) with 3 modes: remote, repo, hub. File ownership split clearly documented. 102 tests (86 existing + 16 new). BUT: Based on old JS architecture, conflicts with current main (TS replatform). Either (1) Port to `packages/squad-cli/src/` TS codebase (non-trivial but design is sound), or (2) Verify if TS codebase already includes remote mode (may be superseded). Recommendation: Brady asks Shayne, "Does current main already have remote mode in TS CLI, or should we port this PR?" |
| 39 | +- **Pattern learned:** Architectural transitions create PR assessment complexity. When a replatform is in-flight, older PRs need "architecture alignment" review before quality review. Check: Is this PR based on the old or new architecture? If old, how deep is the porting work? Does the design survive translation? |
| 40 | +- **Verdict:** 1 ready (merge), 2 safe (merge to dev), 1 requires clarification (redirect to Shayne for superseded-status). No blockers for immediate action. |
| 41 | +- **Output:** Assessment table + compatibility cascade summary provided to Brady. |
| 42 | + |
31 | 43 | ### 2026-03-05T[NOW]: Migration Docs Gap Analysis — Issue #188 File Migration Guidance |
32 | 44 | - **Task:** Brady requested review of migration docs for gaps exposed by issue #188. Users KevinUK and jeremythake hit "Unknown command: doctor" after upgrade (separate CLI bug), but KevinUK also asked critical migration question: "which files/folders exactly are safe to copy to the new .squad?" Verify the docs answer this question; if not, identify what's missing. |
33 | 45 | - **Approach:** Read migration docs, verify against codebase behavior (init/upgrade logic, TEMPLATE_MANIFEST, migrations), trace user question to docs coverage. |
|
0 commit comments