Wish: support for rendering with newlines

[simonmichael]

As inspecting diffs or troubleshooting with one huge line of output is hard.

Pretty indented output like blaze-html's would be a bonus.

Related: hledgerorg/hledger#2321

[chrisdone]

I think this is possible by outputting a Seq of tagged events in the internal StateT. And then one can decide how to layout those events. There might be a performance hit compared with directly outputting to a Builder. I’d have to benchmark it and see if it’s a big hit or a little hit. It might not be much different, don’t know until you bench it. lucid doesn’t bill itself as a high performance library, but e.g. a 2x slow down would probably be considered a regression.

blaze-markup’s pretty printer goes via String, so if you’re using that you might not be concerned about performance. Apparently it doesn’t work correctly, so you might need to fix it first: haskell-servant/servant-blaze#2 jaspervdj/blaze-html#111 jaspervdj/blaze-html#103 It doesn’t look very easy to do it properly. I know the blaze authors added it for debugging, but such is the way of things that it gets held to a standard of complete correctness. 😂

[chrisdone]

Maybe you could provide a reformatting function in a module like .Debug that did the naive thing on a ByteString, which would let you write a trivial pretty printer without people having the wrong expectations?

[listx]

Hmm, does https://github.com/georgefst/prettyprinter-lucid help as a workaround? I haven't tried it yet but it seems like it can do pretty-printing of Lucid's Html type.

Correction: looks like the link I posted is for pretty-printing other things (generic data structures) using HTML output using Lucid. It's not for pretty-printing the HTML itself.